The team mobilizes to search for Jinny Coe, a personal escort who disappeared near her apartment. News anchor Joy-Ann Reid launches a nationwide search for “Sir,” who abducted Gabi and Bella when they were young. Dhan makes a breakthrough with Zeke.
The guys meet a man who says he can prove he has a bloodstained pistol that was owned by outlaw Jesse James. Dale visits a farmer who thinks he found proof of aliens in his own backyard. Plus, the guys try to figure out how two men discovered similar valuable objects about a hundred miles apart in the Midwest.